← Back to catalogue

Sign in to add a photo.

Arethusa Farm

Chocolate Milk

Rich with real cocoa, intensely chocolatey.

Unranked · 2 more reviews
9.09.0
CMI score
1 review
Value

No price data yet.

Quality

avg 9.1

Higher is better. These are the only axes that move the score.

Flavor10.0
Mouthfeel8.0
Aftertaste9.0

What it tastes like

Descriptors, not judgments — they place the milk on a spectrum and deliberately do not affect the score.

Chocolate intensity9.0 · 1 rating
barely chocolateyintensely chocolatey
Cocoa character8.0 · 1 rating
milky & sweetdark & roasty
Sweetness8.0 · 1 rating
barely sweetvery sweet
Thickness7.0 · 1 rating
thin & waterythick & coating
Creaminess8.0 · 1 rating
lean & hollowrich & buttery
Sign in to contributeReviews, photos and sightings all need an account.Add where you found it

Details

Milk base
Whole milk
Cocoa
Dutch-processed
Sweetener
Cane sugar
Storage
Refrigerated
Organic
No
Grass-fed
No

Sizes

SizePackageServingsPer containerPrice
16 oz473 mlBottle1410 cal—

Sign in to add a size this milk comes in.

Nutrition

Nutrition per serving, and per 100 millilitres
NutritionPer serving1 bottle (473 ml)Per 100 mlfor comparing
Calories41087
Total fat17 g3.6 g
Saturated fat9 g1.9 g
Carbohydrate51 g10.8 g
Total sugars47 g9.9 g
Added sugars25 g5.3 g
Protein15 g3.2 g
Sodium300 mg63 mg
Calcium643 mg136 mg

Entered by hand. Updated October 1, 2026.

Sign in to add the nutrition panel from the label.

Ingredients

Grade A whole milk, cane sugar, cocoa processed with alkali, dextrose, corn starch, salt, carrageenan, pure vanilla, and Vitamin D3

Contains carrageenan, a thickener made from red seaweed. See every milk without it.

Reviews (1)

  • 9/10

    Extremely well rounded - the roastiness of the cocoa sings through the initial sip and aftertaste. If you prefer chocolate flavor above all else this is the drink for you

    Flavor: 10Mouthfeel: 8Aftertaste: 9Chocolate intensity: 9Cocoa character: 8Sweetness: 8Thickness: 7Creaminess: 8
    gtcar
    9/11/202600 people found this useful

Where to find it

Reported by people who found it. Confirm a spot to keep it current, or flag it if the milk is gone — 3 people agreeing it is gone retires the pin.

Showing 1 of 1

Loading map…

Pins show the town a milk was reported in, not an exact address. Faded pins have not been confirmed recently. Retailer logos via Wikimedia Commons; used to identify where a product is sold.

  • 🥤Arethusa Farm DairyNew Haven, CT
    Recently confirmed · 1 confirmed

Sign in to report where you found this.